The Real Cost of DIY Branding: What It’s Costing Your Business
When DIY Branding Stops Working
All small businesses or non-profits begin the same way: small. You have an idea and figure out how to make it work. Part of this is coming up with a name and a logo. Or, your brand—which is so much more than just a name and a logo, of course. But you need a visual.
Maybe you doodled some ideas on a napkin while having coffee with a friend. Either way, you probably started scrappy—with Canva, a friend’s help, or a $50 logo. It was resourceful, and it got you started. We all need to take that first step.
But now? You have a small business or non-profit. Whatever it is, it’s growing. And, your brand? You’ve outgrown it.
While the easiest way to get started, DIY branding often creates hidden costs—confusion, inconsistency, and missed growth opportunities. The price was great when you first started, but now it’s time to take your brand to the next level, and allow yourself to thrive from the benefits of professional brand design.
Let’s jump into why those initial “savings” from DIY branding might actually be costing you—and how to get unstuck.
The Hidden Limitations of DIY Branding
Your brand is you. Branding is about creating a recognizable, memorable, and trusted presence in your industry. In fact, branding is integral to your identity as a business or non-profit, from day one and all the way into the future.
DIY branding is how most of us get started. But, branding isn’t everyone’s forte. Nevertheless, using Canva or help from a graphic designer friend is the first step most small businesses or non-profits take.
While convenient, DIY branding suffers from a few major pitfalls.
🧩 No brand foundation – Just visuals, with no strategy or story behind them
Visuals are important—no one would disagree. Someone once said “a picture is worth a thousand words.” But visuals without a strategy or story are no more than pretty images. Having an image or visual in mind to show your industry who you are is key, but oftentimes DIY branding overlooks the importance of having a strong visual built from your brand’s foundation.
🎨 Generic templates – Canva makes it easy, but also makes everyone look the same
Templates exist for a reason—they’re easy and ready to use when you’re in a pinch. But, what’s original about a template? Canva is a user-friendly tool to help flesh out a pretty logo, but remember: you’re not the only one using Canva. There are many common mistakes in Canva branding, but a big one is that everyone else may be using the same template.
🚫 Inconsistent visuals – No brand guidelines = visual chaos
Your brand guideline is the blueprint for your small business or non-profit. Churning out quick images or using templates can seem like an easy way to save time and other valuable resources, but no guideline means visual chaos for your audience.
🤔 Confusing messaging – DIY branding often ignores copy strategy, tone, and clarity
DIY branding is quick and simple, but the convenience often means lack of a strategy when it comes to copy, tone, and clarity. Your messaging should be the same across all platforms because this is how you’re seen. The lack of consistency means a befuddled audience.
🔁 Frequent re-dos – Wasted time reinventing the wheel with each post, email, or product launch
The last thing anyone wants to do is waste valuable time. DIY branding often means rehashing content or taking it back to square one over and over again. The time spent could be invested on a whole portfolio of branding materials always at your fingertips.
What DIY Branding Might Be Costing You
DIY branding not only limits you, it could be costing you—even more than you think. What you save on doing it yourself, can often mean losing revenue in the future.
❌ Missed conversions – Confused audiences don’t buy or donate
Small businesses need revenue from clients and customers, and non-profits need donations from donors to continue helping communities. For each, connecting with an audience is key. However, if your audience isn’t quite sure of your message, it means a missed connection for your small business or non-profit. One long-term impact of poor branding is missed conversion.
❌ Lower trust – Inconsistency = unprofessional = untrustworthy
We’re all customers and clients. Think about the brands you like. Why do you always buy dog food from the same company? Because you trust ‘em. And, why do we trust the brands we love? They’re consistent. Inconsistency comes across as very unprofessional, and unprofessional brands feel untrustworthy. As a small business or non-profit, you want to develop the same customer loyalty.
❌ Brand fatigue – Team members feel uninspired or unsure about how to show up
Over time, you may notice your brand is missing its spark. Your team may feel uninspired or unsure about how to show up and promote your brand. This brand fatigue means a lack of excitement. How do you grow when your team doesn’t know how to support your brand?
❌ Lost opportunities – Partnerships, press, and growth pass you by when your brand looks unprepared
Your DIY brand may be the reason you’re missing out on opportunities for growth. Partners may overlook teaming up with you, or press may be uninterested in giving your the spotlight if your brand looks unprepared. It’s your identity after all, and it should be as exciting as your small business or non-profit. Your brand needs to resonate—it needs to be your opportunity to grow!
💸 More expensive fixes later – Rebranding after the fact costs more than doing it right early on
While DIY branding seems to be a quick, affordable way to initially develop your brand, you’ll most likely need rebranding in the future. Your small business or non-profit will grow, and you’ll find yourself returning back to the drawing board to make your brand catch up with you. Doing it right early on, however, makes sure your brand captures your growth.
What Professional Branding Actually Gives You
Small businesses and non-profits need professional branding that incorporates:
Brand Mission & Values
Target Audience & Positioning
Visual Identity & Consistency
Brand Voice & Messaging
Customer Experience & Engagement
Competing in a crowded market requires clarity, differentiation, and emotional connection. When created together with a professional, your brand will be worth the investment.
🎯 Strategy-first approach – Your visuals are built on your purpose, people, and positioning
Where do you see your small business or non-profit headed? We all have a goal in mind, and your brand needs to work to get you to the finish line—and beyond. Your visuals should grow from your purpose, people, and positioning. They’re an integral part of what you do. Professional branding helps you lay out a strategy and make it come true.
✨ Cohesive brand system – Fonts, colors, logos, voice, templates—all aligned
All aspects of your brand should be aligned. You want to come across as professional and consistent. A cohesive brand system, including fonts, colors, logos, voice, and templates, should be founded on alignment. No matter where, whether at a farmer’s market or on social media through a marketing campaign, cohesion is the key. Professional branding spotlights alignment.
📣 Confidence & clarity – Internally and externally, you know how to show up
In public and in front of your team, you need to show up—and be clear and confident. You know who you are and what you do, and your brand needs to stand behind you and for you. Professional branding makes sure your audience feels as confident as you and knows exactly who you are.
💼 Assets that scale with you – Websites, packaging, email templates that grow with your goals
Your brand isn’t just a pretty image. It’s your identity. Your brand will trek across platforms, like social media, websites, email templates, and even packaging. The brand needs to be able to thrive everywhere. Professional branding helps with it all, and makes sure your assets can grow with you.
✅ A long-term investment – Save time, energy, and money by doing it right
DIY is a cheap way to get started, but as we’ve said, it’ll cost you more overtime. It’s worth the initial investment to start with a professional branding agency. Right from the start, teams like us at Northwest Brand Design will be in it with you. Save time, energy, and money by starting with us.
What It’s Like to Work With Northwest Brand Design
Simply put, branding is an investment, not an expense—it provides long-term value in customer loyalty, market position, and business growth. Once you have your brand strategy laid out, you have a map to future success, including a voice in your industry, return customers, and increased revenue or donations.
That’s why you should work with Northwest Brand Design.
At Northwest Brand Design, we believe that a well-crafted brand isn’t just for big companies—it’s the secret weapon small businesses and non-profits need to stand out, connect with customers, and grow.
We meet you where you are—whether you’re building from scratch or rebuilding from a DIY base, we’re ready to jump in with you and make your brand thrive. Our process is collaborative, strategic, and fun (yes, really!). Your small business or non-profit is your life’s work, and we want you to have fun making your dreams come true. We work with you to make your brand come to life. We’re not just here to make things “look pretty”—we’re here to build a visual identity that works. We want to know your story and so we can help you get it out there.
Book a free Brand Discovery Call to talk about your goals
